ScholarlyGamers

[R] Reviews · 17 articles

Game Reviews

Game reviews here are written to answer two questions at once: how does the thing actually play, and what is it trying to do? Combat, controls, pacing and performance get the same attention as story, structure and the ideas a game leaves behind.

There are no scores. Each review ends with who the game is for and what to expect from it, so the verdict stays readable after a patch, a remaster or a price drop.

An abandoned overgrown gas station at dusk with a barricaded door (AI-generated image)AI

[01] Latest ·

Unturned Review: Survival on Xbox One and PS4

Six years after its Steam debut, Unturned reached Xbox One and PlayStation 4. Its blocky look hides a punishing survival game with more depth than it first appears.

[R] How a review is built

Reading a review

Every review opens with the same spec line. This is what each field records.

  1. Released

    The date this version reached the platform it was played on. Ports often arrive months after the first release.

  2. Reviewed on

    The exact hardware the review was played on. Notes on frame rate, load times and resolution refer to this machine, so an Xbox One X review reads differently from one on a base Xbox One.

  3. Also on

    The other versions available when the review was written.

  4. Developer · Publisher

    Who made the game and who released it. Small studios often self-publish; the line shows which is which.

  5. Price

    The launch price in US dollars on the review date, kept as a record of the launch rather than a current offer.

  6. The verdict

    The closing section says who the game suits and what to expect from it. There is no score, so the verdict still reads correctly after a patch or a price cut.

Spec line from the Moonlighter: Between Dimensions DLC Review – Trick Weapons

The shelf, by platform played

The index

  1. [02]

    Oneechanbara Origin Review

    Tamsoft remade the 2004 cult hack-and-slash and its sequel as one game with a new art style and a new playable character. It looks great and plays exactly like the mid-2000s.

  2. [03]

    Destroy All Humans! Review

    Black Forest Games rebuilt Pandemic's 2005 alien invasion for a new generation and changed almost nothing that mattered. That turns out to be exactly the right call.

  3. [04]

    Moonlighter: Between Dimensions DLC Review – Trick Weapons

    Digital Sun's shopkeeper roguelike already had one of the most addictive loops of its era. Between Dimensions adds new weapons, new risks and a brutal nine-floor dungeon for the endgame.

  4. [05]

    Dogfighter -WW2- Battle Royale Review

    Forty pilots, one shrinking zone and no buildings to hide in. Dogfighter -WW2- moves the battle royale into the sky, and the change works better than its rough edges suggest.

  5. [06]

    2019 Game of the Year Nominations

    2019 brought remakes done right, long-awaited sequels and a few debuts nobody saw coming. These are the games that made the shortlist, and why each one earned its place.

  6. [07]

    My Time At Portia Console Review

    Pathea's crafting life sim reached Xbox One, PlayStation 4 and Switch in 2019. Its freedom to work, farm, dig or court at any pace makes it one of the best games of its kind.

  7. [08]

    The Lion's Song (Switch) Review

    Mi'pu'mi Games set a classic point-and-click adventure among the artists and scientists of early twentieth-century Vienna. Two of its four episodes are among the best adventure storytelling of 2018.

  8. [09]

    Farming Simulator 19 Review: John Deere, Weeds and Multiplayer

    GIANTS Software promised a new engine, new crops, horses, buildable farms and a rebuilt multiplayer. Almost all of it landed, and the result is the strongest game in the series.

  9. [10]

    Audeze Mobius Review: 3D Gaming Headset

    Audeze built its name on high-end planar magnetic headphones costing thousands. The Mobius puts the same driver type in a $399 gaming headset and adds head tracking.

  10. [11]

    HITMAN: Definitive Edition Review – PS4, Xbox One and PC

    IO Interactive rebuilt Agent 47 around six enormous sandboxes. The Definitive Edition puts all of them, and almost everything added since, into one package.

  11. [12]

    God of War Review (Spoiler-Free)

    Santa Monica Studio kept Kratos's past and rebuilt everything else: story, camera, combat, controls and structure. It is one of the best games of its generation.

  12. [13]

    Far Cry 5 Review (Spoiler-Free)

    Ubisoft moved Far Cry to rural Montana and built its open world around a doomsday cult. The result refines nearly everything from Far Cry 4 and shakes up the formula along the way.

  13. [14]

    Sorcery Jokers Review

    Sorcery Jokers looks like a light story about magic and cute characters. Around ten hours in, it becomes something much darker, and much better.

  14. [15]

    Remothered: Tormented Fathers Review

    Stormind Games built a survival horror game around hiding, listening and luring rather than fighting. Six hours long, it rarely lets the tension drop.

  15. [16]

    The Escapists 2 Review

    Team17 and Mouldy Toof kept the trial-and-error heart of The Escapists and fixed much of the friction around it. The result is more accessible without being any less of a puzzle.

  16. [17]

    Utomik Game Subscription Service Review

    Utomik offers unlimited PC games for a monthly fee, streamed in pieces so play starts before the download ends. Its library leans on classics and indies rather than new releases.

[R] Questions

Questions readers ask

Do the game reviews use scores?

No. Each review ends with a verdict that says who the game suits and what to expect from it. A number goes stale after a patch or a price cut; a description of how the game plays does not.

Which platforms are the games reviewed on?

Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 4 and PS4 Pro, Xbox One and Xbox One X, and PC. The spec line at the top of each review names the platform the game was played on and lists the other versions.

Are prices in the reviews current?

They are launch prices in US dollars at the date of the review. Most of these games have since been discounted or bundled, so the price line is a record of the launch rather than a buying guide.

Are there hardware reviews as well as games?

A few. The Audeze Mobius gaming headset and the Utomik game subscription service are reviewed alongside the games.